Hey there, yarn lovers and stitch enthusiasts! Today, we’re diving into a topic that’s been whispered about among knitters and crocheters for ages: the dreaded “Sweater Curse.”
Picture this: You’re happily crafting away, needles or hook in hand, creating a masterpiece of a sweater for your significant other. It’s a labor of love, right? But here’s the twist – many crafters believe that knitting or crocheting a sweater for your romantic partner can spell the end of that relationship. Say what?
The Mythical Sweater Curse
So, what exactly is this infamous sweater curse, and where did it come from? Legend has it that if you knit or crochet a sweater for your beloved, your relationship is bound to unravel faster than a ball of tangled yarn. Some say that the relationship will end before you even finish the sweater! But where did it all start? Honest answer is we just don’t know! We do know that it’s prevalent enough to have it’s own Wikipedia page (means something right?!)
Real or Superstition?
I placed a poll in a large Crochet & Knitting Facebook Group (+200k members) and 1,392 people answered my question. I was surprised by the results to see that 35% of folks had never heard of it before. I encountered talk of the sweater curse when I first started crocheting, and to hear that many people had been crafting for decades and never came across it, was strange to me!
In the comments, some of the folks who responded that they weren’t sure were very clear that although they weren’t sure, they were not willing to risk it!! Those that said it was real, had tangible examples of the curse in action. So what was going on?
The Science of Love (and Sweaters)
Human beings have an inherent inclination to seek out patterns in behavior and our understanding of the world, a cognitive trait that helps us navigate the complexities of life. In the realm of crafting communities like knitting and crochet, where individuals often share common experiences, this tendency can lead to the emergence of perceived patterns. When knitters and crocheters notice a coincidence, like the creation of a sweater coinciding with a relationship ending, they may inadvertently fall prey to pattern recognition. Knowing other crafters who’ve had similar experiences further reinforces the idea of a “Sweater Curse.”
So in this respect the sweater curse is created by knitters and crocheters themselves (unconsciously of course!) by way of confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is a specific type of cognitive bias where individuals tend to give more weight to information that confirms their existing beliefs or hypotheses while ignoring or downplaying evidence that contradicts them. Essentially, people seek out and interpret information in a way that aligns with their preconceived notions, reinforcing their existing views and potentially leading to a skewed or inaccurate understanding of a situation. It’s a classic example of our brains striving to make sense of the world by identifying connections, even when the relationship between making a sweater and a breakup may be purely coincidental.
Relationships
So if the sweater curse is just our tricky brains making wonky attributions, then why are people breaking up after the sweater arrives? Some reasons that others have looked at are:
- Plain ol’ bad timing – Crocheting or knitting a sweater can take quite some time; it’s possible that the relationship would have naturally come to an end anyway over the course of time.
- The prompts an evaluation of the relationship – a gift of such time (and money) might prompt one or other partner to reassess the relationship to see if they are on the same page.
- Aversion – A dislike of sweaters! (Shocking, I know!) But for some, handknit has bad memories or connotations and maybe they just don’t like it. Which can in turn lead to the gift giver feeling unappreciated.
- Misdirected Attention – this one sounds like bad gift giving to me, it’s where the crafter loves their make soooo much that they pester the recipient about wearing it. This is just bad gift giving etiquette!
Avoiding the Sweater Curse
So, if after all that you still believe (and it’s totally okay if you do!) should you abandon your plans to craft that cozy cardigan for your crush? Not at all! The key to avoiding the sweater curse is communication. Talk to your partner about your crafty intentions. Ask about their style preferences and color choices. Better yet, involve them in the process. That way, you’re not just crafting a sweater; you’re crafting a stronger bond.
In the end, the sweater curse is just a fun, quirky superstition. It shouldn’t deter you from sharing your creative passions with your loved ones. So, go ahead, pick up those needles or that hook, and stitch some love into your relationships. After all, there’s nothing quite like a handmade gift to warm the heart – and keep it beating strong! And if things don’t work out, at least you’ll have a fantastic sweater to keep you warm on those chilly nights. 😉
Oh and if you’re looking for a good laugh you should check out this hilarious GQ article by Kate Lindsey where she documents her journey of making her boyfriend a sweater and confronting the curse!
Jack's Yarn Crochet Designs 